Find Balance...  Find Happiness...
Intellectual Forum
You must first log in before you may post comments to the forum.
Go To Topics List  
Forum Topic: First Face Transplant in the U.S. - Ethical or Not?
Screen Name:
Your Post:
 

George S says: Posted: 12/19/2008 12:19 PM EST


George S says: Posted: 12/18/2008 10:57 PM EST

Alright, this is an interesting one. On the one hand, this person (and many others) had such bad facial trauma that affected bone, muscle, skin, and eye, that clearly if there is a way to help her get on with her life in some semblance it should be tried.

My issue is more with the idea- where did this face come from? A cadaver I presume, but I'm sure they didn't have explicit permission to use the person's face. When a person gives themselves to science or donates their organs, it in no way shape or form is implied that someone else could potentially be walking around with your identity.

That is what a face is afterall, an identity.

I think if they are going to be doing these surgeries, they need explicit permission from donors to include the face....

Thoughts

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20081218/lf_nm_life/us_face_transplant_usa_9
Advertisements